Where Anonymity Stops and Law Begins

judges court gavel on a laptop computerOnline anonymity sure does sound appealing, and in most cases it is. However, when you begin to abuse the system, the law steps in. One of the biggest perks of hiding identity online is the freedom of speech, which creates a boundary-less atmosphere. While alluring, it is easy to make crass comments that might not come out in real life. Sometimes, these types of comments or posts can go too far, to the point of degrading others.

Typically, if a person feels victimized, they can bring their issue to court. Online or not, harassment is illegal, and is also worthy of a trial. More and more online harassment cases are springing up due to extensive internet communication. Many of these trials are not just about battling with harassment, but they also deal with the issue that the victim doesn’t know who actually was harassing them in the first place.

As a social network user myself, I know how easy it can seem to just hide your identity and shout out whatever you’re really thinking. But even though it seems awfully tempting, I wouldn’t recommend it; especially if you plan on using it to insult or harass others online. Aside from promoting this for peace-keeping purposes, I also know how easily the court can trace your identity if need be. Essentially, unless you fight for your right to keep your anonymity in court, it will be disclosed. Even then, it is not guaranteed that your personal information will be withheld– it’s up to the judge! Freedom of speech is a right, however carrying this over to the online world is a new concept that the courts are dealing with. The more court cases that occur, the more likely a law that prohibits anonymous harassment online will be created. At this point however, it varies trial by trial.

One recent example of an anonymity harassment case deals with a woman from New York named Rosemary Port who was blogging about a fashion model. In her blog, she proceeded to call the model degrading names. After seeing the comments, the model demanded the name of the blogger and  “it took a court order to reveal her identity” (Whitelaw). But just like that, Rosemary Port went from being anonymous online to having her name in the New York Post.

It is a safe tip to assume that “Internet users should never assume that they will remain anonymous” (Whitelaw). Even if you go out of your way to purchase online anonymity tools, you must be cautious. Remaining anonymous to avoid viruses is one thing, but doing so to talk down on others is another. Once harassment is brought up in court because of anonymity issues, it is likely that the information will be revealed. Just because you might hide yourself behind another name does not mean that your real information is nowhere to be found. There are tracking devices and software that courts can use to obtain information. Not to mention that most sites store your information into their database.

Advertisements

To Ban or Not To Ban: A Commentary on Anonymous Commenting

One of the features of the internet that many like the most is the ability to become anonymous. There’s something extremely appealing about being able to erase your identity. In many occasions, this can be a blessing while in others, it’s a definite curse.

Anonymity in comments has many benefits. First, it gives the writer the ability to express their opinions on things free from judgment or accountability. It’s very freeing to have the ability to say your unpopular opinion on any given popular topic without fear of people being able to attack you directly for doing so. I can tell you from experience that being able to say how much you dislike One Direction without the fans of One Direction knowing who you are is a very nice experience. However despite this freeing aspect, anonymous commenting has many obvious drawbacks.

Untitled-2The ability to speak anonymously on the internet gives people power. While some can act civilized with this power, others find themselves overwhelmed and abuse it. Anonymous commenting has lead to the harassment of many individuals throughout its existence. In this article from the New York Times, the topic of anonymous commenting in news sites is discussed as more and more news sites consider eliminating anonymous commenting all together. This is due to people abusing the power anonymity gives them. Anonymous people can say anything they want without consequence as long as they don’t show who they are. They can tell someone to kill themselves over their opinion on a certain entertainer or politician if they want to. And what happens when someone takes this advice to heart?

But many argue that removing anonymous commenting completely takes away our right as Americans to free speech. This is a valid point to consider. Anonymous commenting, when not abused, is a wonderful privilege we have today. It’s an issue that will be forever debated as long as people continue to abuse it. For now, I saw we just take what anonymous people on the internet say with a grain of salt and a stiff upper lip. We mustn’t let those who abuse the anonymity of the internet win.